Issues №19 (November) / Issues of the magazine for 2018 / Issues / Internauka

Publishing house "Internauka" / Issues / Issues of the magazine for 2018 / Issues №19 (November)

Issues №19 (November)

https://doi.org/10.25313/2520-2057-2018-20

Scientific journal "Internauka" for 2024

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issue №2 (February)

Issue №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Economic Sciences" (2024)

Issue №10 (October)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issue №2 (February)

Issue №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Juridical Sciences" (2024)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issue №2 (February)

Issue №1 (January)

Public Administration and National Security (2024)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issue №2 (February)

Issue №1 (January)

Conferences 2024

ІІ International scientific conference "Actual problems of social and humanitarian sciences in the conditions of transformational changes" (Prague, Czech Republic), May 30, 2024

Scientific journal "Internauka" for 2023

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Economic Sciences" (2023)

Issue №12 (December)

Issue №11 (November)

Issue №10 (October)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issue №2 (February)

Issue №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Juridical Sciences" (2023)

Issue №12 (December)

Issue №11 (November)

Issue №10 (October)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issue №2 (February)

Issue №1 (January)

Public Administration and National Security (2023)

Issue №11 (December)

Issue №10 (November)

Issue №9 (October)

Issue №8 (September)

Issue №7 (August)

Issue №6 (July)

Issue №5 (June)

Issue №4 (May)

Issue №3 (April)

Issue №2 (March)

Issue №1 (February)

Conferences 2023

International scientific conference "Actual problems of social and humanitarian sciences in the conditions of transformational changes" (Prague, Czech Republic), December 12, 2023

ХІV International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development" (Prague, Czech Republic), September 28, 2023

VІІІ ISPIC "ECONOMICS, FINANCE, BANKING AND EDUCATION: CURRENT ISSUES OF DEVELOPMENT, ACHIEVEMENTS AND INNOVATIONS", Odesa-Ostrava, Ukraine-Czech Republic, April 6-7, 2023

Scientific journal "Internauka" for 2022

Issue №15 (December)

Issue №14 (November)

Issue №13 (November)

Issue №12 (October)

Issue №11 (September)

Issue №10 (September)

Issue №9 (August)

Issue №8 (July)

Issue №7 (June)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (February-March)

Issue №2 (February)

Issue №1 (January)

Scientific journal "Internauka" for 2021

Issue №19 (December)

Issue №18 (December)

Issue №17 (November)

Issue №16 (November)

Issue №15 (October)

Issue №14 (October)

Issue №13 (September)

Issue №12 (September)

Issue №11 (August)

Issue №10 (July)

Issue №9 (July)

Issue №8 (June)

Issue №7 (June)

Issue №6 (May)

Issue №5 (April)

Issue №4 (March)

Issue №3 (February)

Issue №2 (February)

Issue №1 (January)

Scientific journal "Internauka" for 2020

Scientific journal "Internauka" for 2019

Issues №18 (December)

Issues №17 (December)

Issues №16 (November)

Issues №15 (November)

Issues №14 (October)

Issues №13 (October)

Issues №12 (August)

Issues №11 (July)

Issues №10 (June)

Issues №9 (June)

Issues №8 (May)

Issues №6 (May)

Issues №6 (April)

Issues №5 (April)

Issues №4 (March)

Issues №3 (February)

Issues №2 (February)

Issues №1 (January)

Issues of the magazine for 2018

Scientific Journal "Internauka" (2017)

Выпуск №18 (December)

Выпуск №17 (December)

Выпуск №16 (November)

Выпуск №15 (November)

Issues №14 (October)

Issue №13 (September)

Issues №12 (August)

Issues №11 (July)

Issues №10 (July)

Issues №9 (June)

Issues №8 (June)

Issues №7 (May)

Issues №6 (May)

Issues №5 (April)

Issues №4 (April)

Issues №3 (March)

Issues №2 (February)

Issues №1 (January)

Scientific Journal "Internauka" (2016)

Issue №12 (December)

Issue №11 (November)

Issue №10 (October)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issues №5 (May)

Issues №4 (April)

Issues №3 (March)

Issues №2 (February)

Issues №1 (January)

Scientific Journal "Internauka" (2015)

Issue №9 (December)

Issue №8 (November)

Issue №7 (October)

Issue №6 (September)

Issue №5 (August)

Issue №4 (July)

Issue №3 (May-June)

Issue №2 (March-April)

Issues №1 (January-February)

Scientific Journal "Internauka" (2014)

Issue №11 (November-december)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Economic Sciences" (2022)

Issue №12 (December)

Issue №11 (November)

Issue №10 (October)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issue №2 (Fabruary)

Issue №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Economic Sciences" (2021)

Issue №12 (December)

Issue №11 (November)

Issue №10 (October)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issue №2 (February)

Issues №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Economic Sciences" (2020)

Issue №12 (December)

Issue №11 (November)

Issue №10 (October)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issues №2 (February)

Issues №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Economic Sciences" (2019)

Issues №12 (December)

Issues №11 (November)

Issues №10 (October)

Issues №9 (September)

Issues №8 (August)

Issues №7 (July)

Issues №6 (June)

Issues №5 (May)

Issues №4 (April)

Issues №3 (March)

Issues №2 (February)

Issues №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Economic Sciences" (2018)

Issues №12 (December)

Issues №11 (November)

Issues №10 (October)

Issues №9 (September)

Issues №8 (August)

Issues №7 (July)

Issues №6 (June)

Issues №5 (May)

Issues №4 (April)

Issues №3 (March)

Issues №2 (February)

Issues №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Economic Sciences" (2017)

Issues №8 (December)

Issues №7 (November)

Issues №6 (October)

Issues №5 (July)

Issues №4 (June)

Issues №3 (March)

Issues №2 (February)

Issues №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Juridical Sciences" (2022)

Issue №12 (December)

Issue №11 (November)

Issue №10 (October)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (June)

Issue №4 (May)

Issue №3 (April)

Issue №2 (February-March)

Issue №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Juridical Sciences" (2021)

Issue №12 (December)

Issue №11 (November)

Issue №10 (October)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issue №2 (February)

Issue №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Juridical Sciences" (2020)

Issue №12 (December)

Issue №11 (November)

Issue №10 (October)

Issue №9 (September)

Issue №8 (August)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6 (June)

Issue №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issues №2 (February)

Issues №1 (January)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Juridical Sciences" (2019)

Issues №8 (December)

Issues №7 (November)

Issues №6 (October)

Issues №5 (August)

Issues №4 (June)

Issues №3 (May)

Issues №2 (April)

Issues №1 (March)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Juridical Sciences" (2018)

Issues №9 (December)

Issues №8 (October)

Issues №7 (September)

Issues №6 (August)

Issues №5 (July)

Issues №4 (June)

Issues №3 (May)

Issues №2 (April)

Issues №1 (February)

International Scientific Journal "Internauka". Series: "Juridical Sciences" (2017)

Issues №5 (November)

Issues №4 (October)

Issues №3 (August)

Issues №2 (February)

Issues №1 (January)

Public Administration and National Security (2022)

Issue №8 (December)

Issue №7 (October)

Issue №6 (September)

Issue №5 (August)

Issue №4 (July)

Issue №3 (May)

Issue №2 (March)

Issue №1 (January)

Public Administration and National Security (2021)

Issue №6 (November-December)

Issue №5 (September-October)

Issue №4 (July-August)

Issue №3 (May-June)

Issue №2 (March-April)

Issues №1 (January-February)

Public Administration and National Security (2020)

Issue №8 (September-December)

Issue №7 (July)

Issue №6/1 (June)

Issues №6 (June)

Issues №5 (May)

Issue №4 (April)

Issue №3 (March)

Issues №2 (Februry)

Issues №1 (January)

Public Administration and National Security (2019)

Issue №6 (December)

Issues №5 (November)

Issues №4 (September)

Issues №3 (August)

Issues №2 (May)

Issues №1 (April)

Public Administration and National Security (2018)

Issues №3 (November)

Issues №2 (October)

Issues №1 (September)

Conferences 2022

XIІІ International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development", December 29, 2022 (Prague, Czech Republic)

XIІ International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development", September 28, 2022 (Prague, Czech Republic)

XІ International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development", August 30, 2022 (Prague, Czech Republic)

X International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development", June 29, 2022 (Prague, Czech Republic)

Conferences 2021

IX International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development", May 31, 2021 (Prague, Czech Republic)

VIІІ International scientific conference "Science and Global Studies", May 17, 2021 (Prague, Czech Republic)

VІII International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development", April 30, 2021 (Prague, Czech Republic)

VIІ International scientific conference "Science and Global Studies", April 15, 2021 (Prague, Czech Republic)

VII International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development", March 31, 2021 (Prague, Czech Republic)

VI International scientific conference "Science and Global Studies", February 28, 2021 (Prague, Czech Republic)

VI International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development" (Prague, Czech Republic), February 15, 2021

Conferences 2020

V International scientific conference "Science and Global Studies", December 30, 2020 (Prague, Czech Republic)

V International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development" (Prague, Czech Republic), December 28, 2020

IV International scientific conference "Science and Global Studies", November 30, 2020 (Prague, Czech Republic)

IV International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development" (Prague, Czech Republic), November 27, 2020

III International scientific conference "Science and Global Studies", October 30, 2020 (Prague, Czech Republic)

III International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development" (Bratislava, Vienna), May 26, 2020

II International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development" (Bratislava, Vienna), April 27, 2020

Science and Global Studies, March 31, 2020 (Bratislava, Slovakia)

International scientific conference "Scientific research: the paradigm of innovative development" (Bratislava, Vienna), March 25, 2020

Conference 2019

Science and Global Studies, December 30, 2019 (Bratislava, Slovakia)

XLV International Scientific and Practical Conference "Actual problems of modern science" 11/28/2019 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XLIV International Scientific and Practical Conference "Actual problems of modern science" 10/30/2019 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XLIIІ International Scientific and Practical Conference "Actual problems of modern science" 08/29/2019 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XLIIІ International Scientific and Practical Conference "Actual problems of modern science" 07/30/2019 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XLII International Scientific and Practical Conference "Actual problems of modern science" 06/27/2019 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XLI International Scientific and Practical Conference "Actual problems of modern science" 05/30/2019 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XL International Scientific and Practical Conference "Actual problems of modern science" 03/28/2019 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ISPC "Digital transformation and innovation in economics, law, government, science and educational processes", March 18-21, 2019

XXXIX International Scientific and Practical Conference "Actual problems of modern science" 02/27/2019 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XIII International scientific and practical conference «Scientific Debate: the Issues of Economy and Finance», 01/31/2019 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XXXVIII International Scientific and Practical Conference "Actual problems of modern science" 01/30/2019 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

Conference 2018

XXXVII International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 12/28/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XXXVI International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 11/29/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XIII International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of Economics and Finance», 10/31/2018 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XXXV International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 10/30/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XXXIV International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 09/28/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ХXXIII International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 08/30/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ХXXII International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 07/31/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XIІ International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of Economics and Finance», 07/31/2018 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

ХXXI International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 06/29/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XІ International scientific-practical conference «Global Issues of Economy and Finance», 31.05.2018 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

ХXX International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 05/30/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ХXIX International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 04/30/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ХXVIІI International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 03/29/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ІІІ ISPC «Economics, Finance and Management in the XXI Century: Analysis of Trends and Development Prospects», March 19-22, 2018 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

X International scientific and practical conference «The global problems of economy and finance», 02/28/2018 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

ХXVІI International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 02/27/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ХXVI International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 01/30/2018 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

Conference 2017

XІІ International scientific and practical conference «Scientific debate: the issue of Economy and Finance», 12/29/2017 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

ХXV International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 12/28/2017 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ХXIV International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 11/29/2017 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XІ International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of Economics and Finance», 10/31/2017 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XІ International scientific and practical conference «Scientific debate: the issue of Economy and Finance», 09/29/2017 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

ХXIІІ International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 09/28/2017 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

X International scientific-practical conference "Actual problems of Economics and Finance", 07/31/2017 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XXII International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 07/28/2017 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XXI International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 06/29/2017 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

IX International scientific and practical conference «The global problems of economy and finance», 05/31/2017 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XX International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 05/30/2017 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

"Trends in the development of national economies: economic and legal dimension" 18-19.05.2017 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Council)

XIX International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 04/27/2017 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

IX International scientific-practical conference "Scientific debate: the issue of economy and financ", 03/31/2017 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XVIII International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 03/30/2017 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ISPC «Economics, Finance and Management in the XXI Century: Analysis of Trends and Development Prospects», March 20–23, 2017 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

VIII International scientific-practical conference "The global problems of economy and finance", 02/27/2017 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XVII International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 02/27/2017 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

VIII International scientific and practical conference "Actual problems of economy and finance", 01/31/2017 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XVI International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 01/30/2017 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

Conference 2016

XV International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 12/28/2016 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

VIII International scientific-practical conference "Scientific debate: the issue of economy and financ", 28.12.2016 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

VII International scientific-practical conference "The global problems of economy and finance", 30.11.2016 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XIV International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 11/29/2016 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

VII International scientific and practical conference "Actual problems of economy and finance", 10/31/2016 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XIІI International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 10/28/2016 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

VII International scientific and practical conference «Scientific debate: the issue of economy and finance», 09/30/2016 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

XII International scientific and practical conference «Actual problems of modern science», 09/29/2016 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

XІ International scientific-practical conference "Actual problems of modern science", 08/30/2016 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ІV International scientific-practical conference "Economics and Management in the XXI century: analysis of trends and prospe", 29.07.2016

X International scientific-practical conference "Actual problems of modern science", 07/28/2016 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

VІ International Scientific-Practical Conference "Actual problems of Economy and Finance", 30.06.2016 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

IX International scientific-practical conference "Actual problems of modern science", 06/29/2016 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

VI International scientific-practical conference "Scientific debate: the issue of economy and finance", 31.05.2016 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

VIII International scientific-practical conference "Actual problems of modern science", 05/30/2016 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

V International scientific-practical conference "The global problems of economy and finance", 29.04.2016 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

VII International scientific-practical conference "Actual problems of modern science", 04/28/2016 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

VI International scientific-practical conference "Actual problems of modern science", 03/31/2016 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

ІІ International scientific-practical conference "Economics and Management in the XXI century: analysis of trends and prospe", 30.03.2016

V International Scientific-Practical Conference "Actual problems of Economy and Finance", 21-24.03.2016 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

V International scientific-practical conference "Scientific debate: the issue of economy and finance", 26.06.2016 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

II International Scientific and Practical Conference “Scientific Debate: Actual Problems of Medicine” 02/20/2016 (Joint conference with International Scientific Centre)

Conference 2015

IV International scientific-practical conference "Actual problems of modern science", 12/29/2015 (Joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

IV International scientific-practical conference "The global problems of economy and finance", 28.12.2015 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

IV International scientific-practical conference "Actual problems of economy and finance", 30.11.2015 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

IV International scientific-practical conference "Scientific debate: the issue of economy and finance", 29.10.2015 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

International scientific and practical conference “Scientific debate: actual problems of medicine” 10/28/2015 (Joint conference with International Scientific Centre)

III International scientific-practical conference "The global problems of economy and finance," 9/30/2015 (Joint conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

III International scientific-practical conference "Actual problems of economy and finance," 8/31/2015 (Joint Conference with the Financial and Economic Scientific Union

"The scientific debate: the issue of Economy and Finance", 30.06.2015 (Joint conference with Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

Actual problems of modern science, 06/29/2015 (joint conference with the International Scientific Centre)

Global problems of the economy and finances, 28.05.2015 (Joint conference with Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

Actual problems of the economy and finances, 29.04.2015 (Joint conference with Financial and Economic Scientific Union)

Scientific debate: the issue of Economy and Finance, 03/31/2015 (Joint Conference on Financial and Economic scientific board)

Actual problems of the modern science, 27.03.2015 (Joint conference with International Scientific Center)

Global problems economic and finance, 27.02.2015 (Joint conference with the financial and economic research council)

Conference 2014

Scientific debate: Issues of economy and finance, 20 november 2014

Actual problems of Economics and Finance, 29.12.2014 (Joint Conference of the financial and economic Research Council)

Monographs

ECONOMY, FINANCE, LAW: CURRENT PROBLEMS AND DEVELOPMENT PROSPECTS (2023)

PEDAGOGY AND PSYCHOLOGY IN THE MODERN WORLD: THEORETICAL AND PRACTICAL ASPECTS

ECONOMY, FINANCE, LAW: CURRENT PROBLEMS AND DEVELOPMENT PROSPECTS

Geographical sciences2

Medical sciences1

Technical sciences12

Chemical sciences1

Legal science16

Economic sciences14

Dubrova N. P.Zubko O. V.Sotnikov S. A.

Дуброва Н. П., Зубко О. В., Сотніков С. О. Забезпечення конкурентоспроможності банків в умовах фінансової кризи // Міжнародний науковий журнал "Інтернаука". — 2018. — №20.

Branch of science: Economic sciences

Download article (pdf)