Видавничий дім «Інтернаука» — на головну

Господарське право; господарсько-процесуальне право Українською Відкритий доступ

Субсидіарна відповідальність у справі про банкрутство: правова природа та значення для відокремленого провадження

Райчева Світлана Іванівна

Науковий журнал «Сучасна доктрина права», № 5, травень 2025

English

Subsidiary Liability in Bankruptcy Case: Legal Nature and Significance for Separate Proceedings

Abstract. Introduction. This scholarly article is devoted to the institution of subsidiary liability in bankruptcy proceedings under Ukrainian law, with particular attention to its theoretical foundations and comparative legal aspects. The article identifies key factors influencing the effectiveness of subsidiary liability in the context of bankruptcy cases, highlighting the important role of judicial practice and legal regulation. The practical importance of subsidiary liability in protecting creditors’ rights is also analyzed. This legal mechanism enables the imposition of liability on individuals (founders or executives) for the obligations of a legal entity when the latter is unable to fulfill its liabilities due to bankruptcy. Despite the potential of this instrument, legislative and judicial improvements are needed to ensure its effective application. Purpose. Comprehensive analysis of the institution of subsidiary liability in the bankruptcy procedure in Ukrainian law, in particular its legal nature, grounds for application, limits and forms of implementation, practice of application. Materials and Methods. The article uses a complex methodological approach, which includes both general scientific and special methods of legal research. The system-structural method was applied to determine the role of the institution of subsidiary liability in the bankruptcy procedure in Ukrainian law. The comparative legal method was used to analyze Ukrainian and international scientific sources, the regulatory framework and the practice of using grounds for application, limits and forms of implementation of subsidiary liability. Results. The main factors affecting the effectiveness of the application of subsidiary liability in the context of bankruptcy cases are identified, among which legal regulation and judicial practice occupy an important place. Theoretical issues related to the nature and essence of subsidiary liability are examined, as well as its place within the legal framework governing insolvency. Special emphasis is placed on the need for a clear definition of the conditions for imposing subsidiary liability and the mechanisms for its implementation, in order to prevent abuse and manipulation by company founders or managers. Based on an analysis of current legislation and established case law, the article proposes a definition of subsidiary liability in bankruptcy as a statutorily provided exceptional type of financial liability imposed on controlling persons of the debtor, in cases where their proven wrongful conduct (acts or omissions) has caused the debtor’s persistent insolvency, and the debtor's estate is insufficient to satisfy creditor claims. This liability is characterized by its auxiliary (additional) nature relative to the debtor’s primary obligation. It is proposed to develop the concept of "illegal actions in case of bankruptcy" and to include in the scope of such actions obstruction of the arbitration manager in the exercise of his powers. The necessity of distinguishing procedural actions of the court regarding the establishment of the circle of guilty persons within the framework of the main bankruptcy case and consideration of a property dispute in a separate lawsuit proceeding for the recovery of the amount of subsidiary liability is substantiated. Discussion. It is concluded that a proper balance must be maintained between the protection of creditors’ rights and the preservation of the legal foundations for entrepreneurial activity, which is a vital component of the country's economic development. Taking into account the expansion of grounds for imposing subsidiary liability on guilty persons in bankruptcy cases, it is important to continue research in terms of studying the qualifying signs of guilt, the range of sufficient and admissible evidence of guilt, and the search for optimal forms of consideration of this type of property dispute.

Keywords: subsidiary liability; insolvency; bankruptcy proceedings; debtor; controlling person; leading to bankruptcy; illegal actions in case of bankruptcy; property dispute; arbitration manager; separate proceedings; commercial procedure

Як цитувати

Райчева С. І. Субсидіарна відповідальність у справі про банкрутство: правова природа та значення для відокремленого провадження // Міжнародний науковий журнал "Інтернаука". Серія: "Юридичні науки". – 2025. – № 5. https://doi.org/10.25313/2520-2308-2025-5-11059

@article{internauka11059,
  author   = {Райчева, Світлана Іванівна},
  title    = {Субсидіарна відповідальність у справі про банкрутство: правова природа та значення для відокремленого провадження},
  journal  = {Науковий журнал «Сучасна доктрина права»},
  year     = {2025},
  number   = {5},
  doi      = {10.25313/2520-2308-2025-5-11059},
  url      = {https://www.inter-nauka.com/issues/law2025/5/11059}
}
TY  - JOUR
AU  - Райчева, Світлана Іванівна
TI  - Субсидіарна відповідальність у справі про банкрутство: правова природа та значення для відокремленого провадження
JO  - Науковий журнал «Сучасна доктрина права»
PY  - 2025
IS  - 5
SN  - 2520-2308
DO  - 10.25313/2520-2308-2025-5-11059
UR  - https://www.inter-nauka.com/issues/law2025/5/11059
LA  - uk
ER  - 

Текст статті

Або відкрийте файл PDF

PDF, 385 КБ — Завантажити PDF

Як цитувати

Райчева С. І. Субсидіарна відповідальність у справі про банкрутство: правова природа та значення для відокремленого провадження // Міжнародний науковий журнал "Інтернаука". Серія: "Юридичні науки". – 2025. – № 5. https://doi.org/10.25313/2520-2308-2025-5-11059

@article{internauka11059,
  author   = {Райчева, Світлана Іванівна},
  title    = {Субсидіарна відповідальність у справі про банкрутство: правова природа та значення для відокремленого провадження},
  journal  = {Науковий журнал «Сучасна доктрина права»},
  year     = {2025},
  number   = {5},
  doi      = {10.25313/2520-2308-2025-5-11059},
  url      = {https://www.inter-nauka.com/issues/law2025/5/11059}
}
TY  - JOUR
AU  - Райчева, Світлана Іванівна
TI  - Субсидіарна відповідальність у справі про банкрутство: правова природа та значення для відокремленого провадження
JO  - Науковий журнал «Сучасна доктрина права»
PY  - 2025
IS  - 5
SN  - 2520-2308
DO  - 10.25313/2520-2308-2025-5-11059
UR  - https://www.inter-nauka.com/issues/law2025/5/11059
LA  - uk
ER  -